The CW Source

Hey Jackie, Mia, Sarah!!!

I just finished listening to your podcasts, both the first and fifth season of One Tree Hill. I had a great time hearing your opinions, and I gotta say I laughed out loud a lot.
I am so excited for the 6th season, and I will be looking forward to your podcast. I hope you will do season 2 soon.

jackie, mia, sarah, thank you guys so much for doing these podcasts for us, i know u guys have a lot of other shows to podcast, but it's so cool that u did commentaries just for us fans! u guys are really interesting, and i love ur arguments on storylines/characters/random situations i hope u guys are gonna continue with season 2, although its my least fave season, it is filled with the most drama and depression of the 5! so i think it will prompt much heated debates/arguments between the 3 of u!

hey guys! u 3 are so entertaining, i wanted to thank you for podcasting season 1, i always listened every monday and ur arguments are really interesting to listen to, i'm actually sad that u guys arent podcasting season 2 :-( i hope u will reconsider, i know u have to do other shows plus the current seasons are all starting on the cw, but plz plz do podcast season 2 when u guys have time! thanks so much and cant wait to hear from you guys in a couple weeks!

while you are taking a break def watch both of the commentaries for the finale! Both are HILARIOUS!

Loved the podcasts for the whole first season!

but please dont take a break
I always look forward to your podcasts
especially now that you're going to season 2!
RECONSIDER!! lol

I listened to this podcast yesterday, but I forgot to thank you ladies for a great way to spend the summer hiatus. I was so excited to hear your thoughts every week and I am sad to know that I won't hear anymore until September:(.

Will you be continuing with season two in September or will you girls only be podcasting the current episodes? I think I speak for all the listeners: Please podcast season 2! I love to hear other opinions of this amazing show.

PS: I forgot to ask, did you all watch the s1 finale commentary with the core 5? If not, go do it NOW! Its amazing, so hilarious, I really really really hope that we get another one of them, perhaps for the series finale!?! But seriously its a must watch/listen, cause it will just crack you up!

WOW so season 1 is done and over with. It was a really good season, a strong one for OTH, not the best but a really good one. I loved how in the season finale everything is so different from the season premiere, seriously if you watch those 2 episodes back to back you would be like WTF!?! haha One of the things I love about OTH and the end of this season, and that goes into s2 is the Lucas and Nathan relationship, its one of the greatest, I love when they are actually brothers. Its soo great in s2 when L helps N out so much. Ok so I totally understand all your Lucas hate at the moment, cause I had it to. Its funny cause I started watching the show b/c of CMM so naturally Lucas was my favorite until he cheated on Brooke, and by the end of s1 I couldn't stand him just like you girls can't. But I PROMISE you Lucas will redeem himself majorly in s2. That is actually my favorite Lucas of all 5 seasons, s2 Lucas is just amazing all around. He is a great friend and caring and just wants to make all the wrongs he did in s1 right. Like alot of people have said, the first part of s2 is kinda boring and drags along but by like 209/210 things start to pick up and it gets better. You are going to be meeting alot of new people, some are totally worth it (Andy) and some I wish would have just died (Felix). I said it in my commment on the last podcast, s2 wasn't one of my favorites until I went back and rewatched it. Its got some good stuff, especially in the 2nd half. But no matter how you feel just sit through s2 cause season 3 will be the greatest reward and treat, its the best season of OTH so far, and will probably remain it forever. THANK you girls so much for doing this, I love your podcasts so much, I am addicted. I'm so sad that we won't get another one until s6 starts, :( I really hope you reconsider, I mean we have like 3 1/2 weeks left til s6 airs, I don't think I can go that long w/o hearing your hilarious thoughts on my favorite show. So PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE reconsider and start on s2 now!! :) But thanks again, you girls rock, can't wait for your thoughts on the rest of the show..... s2=Amazing Brucas buildup!! YAY

First off .. break from OTH podcasting!! Nooooo! Please reconsider! I love these podcasts!

Back to this podcast though .. I too hate how Lucas centric everything is. It's ironic that in the beginning everyone thought Lucas had the short end of the stick when it came to his life compared to Nathan yet at the end it's Nathan that had the short stick not only with having to live with Dan but also with his pitiful screen time. Nathans storylines are always more fascinating and should be explored more but it's always Lucas that gets the screen time. How hard is it to convey a love triangle and whoring around on screen? Welcome to OTH indeed Sarah.

Anyway ... Deb and Keith were pretty shocking weren't they? They were always pleasant together so I don't know ... people will do a lot of stuff to find comfort.

It wouldn't be OTH without unlocked doors and everyone knows that LOL

Legal age to get married in NC is 16 years old. 2 of my friends got married at 16, but they had to go to NC (from FL) to do it.

You will see more of the Naley wedding in season 2.

I don't think that Lucas could really have done anything BUT leave P & B a note. If he told them in person, they would have been like "good riddance, we don't want to hear your explanation," and he wouldn't have been able to tell them what he wanted.

Can't wait until you watch season 2! It's tied with season 3 for my favorite!

I think probably the best quote ever from the podcasts was when Jackie said something like "We miss out on so much because we have to watch Lucas sulk" and Mia said, "Welcome to One Tree Hill." Hahaha perfection. I agree with that 150%.

I want to personally say thanks to you guys for doing this. I really enjoyed listening to them all and hearing your thoughts. Plus it was a great chance to revisit the old episodes. I'm glad you guys enjoyed it, too. Us listeners were on to something when we told you to watch!

Yes this episode was so awesome. I forgot about some of the stuff as well just like Den and Keith I mean OMG. Sarah I think you are right about Brooke and Peyton's plan. It was just a way to get Nikki out of their lives. Well actually we don't know if this is the last game that Dan would coach because of Whitey's test results. with the way they ended it they made it seem like bad results. I love Dan's final words "Deb you better hope I die." Dan is just made to hate but Lucas well he's kinda annoying now. Just like you guys said he's too judgemental. But the difference from season 1 to season 5 is that they have matured so that they can't just throw parties like everyday.

Oh and yes I love the supernatural podcasts. But NO NO NO you have to be back podcasting One Tree Hill before season 6 shows. I wanna know when you guys are gonna get to season 4 which is one of my faves. I've loved every single podcast upi must do more soon.

I hope you guys start watching and podcasting for Season 2 really soon. personally, one of my favorite seasons. the second half is much better than the first half though, so sit tight.
you girls are hilarious and i laugh every time i listen to your oth podcasts.
much love!

I don't think I can wait until Season 6 to hear you talk about One Tree Hill again. Your podcasts are great. I started watching OTH a few months ago on Soapnet, became obsessed and got through watching all 5 seasons in a matter of 2 weeks, so all your podcasts are great for me 'cause the show is still so fresh in my mind. I agree with so much that you say...and I laugh so much because you are saying exactly what I am thinking. Don't be gone to long, you make my commute to work go so much faster.

Some things I learned and upheld while listening to your podcasts:
Dismiss all disbelief, anything can, will, and should happen in Tree Hill.
Do not count minutes, hours, days, weeks, months, years, because the OTH timeline is irrevocably screwed up.
It's just a TV Show, so enjoy it.
Thanks for the great podcast season, ladies!

I think you are being too harsh on Lucas. First of all, his reaction to Haley and Nathan... he was shocked and he was trying not to make a big deal out of it but he was frustrated.

The reason why he is leaving, is because he screwed up. He feels badly about what he did to Brooke and Peyton and he doesn't know how to deal with it. He feels leaving OTH will make his and everyone else's life better. And the way you guys complain about him... you'd think you'd agree!

Also, not telling Peyton and Brooke he was leaving... well neither of them really want tot alk to him right now, so I don't really think he is required to talk to them!

I was also confused by the whole peyton and Brooke thing involving Nikki and Jake. I am so glad that brooke didn't betray Jake's location.

This was a great season finale though, with all of the suprises and trickery happening.

Thanks for the podcasts of season 1 ladies... I may not agree with... well most of what you have had to say=p but I did enjoy listening to you!!

I can't wait until you do season 2! However, I am excited for rest of Season One of Supernatural though! Does this mean we get 2 a week of the boys? Please say yes!